- Best Anime Overall 2010
- Best Story 2010
- Best Character Development 2010
- Best Animation / Artwork 2010
- Best Action Anime 2010
- Best Adventure / Fantasy Anime 2010
- Best Drama Anime 2010
- Best Romance Anime 2010
- Best Comedy Anime 2010
- Best Ecchi Anime 2010
- Best Science-Fiction 2010
- Best Sports Anime 2010
- Best Horror / Thriller / Mystery 2010
- Best Slice-Of-Life Anime 2010
- Best Newcomer Anime 2010
- [2013] Best Action/Adventure Series
- [2013] Best Comedy Series
- [2013] Best Drama Series
- [2013] Best Ecchi Series
- [2013] Best Fantasy Series
- [2013] Best Horror/Supernatural/Mystery Series
- [2013] Best Romance Series
- [2013] Best Science-Fiction Series
- [2013] Best Slice-of-Life
- [2013] Best Sports/Games/Tournaments Series
- [2013] Best OVA/OAV/ONA/Special
- [2013] Best Opening Theme
- [2013] Best Ending Theme
- [2013] Favorite Female Character
- [2013] Favorite Male Character
- [2013] Best Overall Series
- (2014) Best Overall Series
- (2014) Best Opening Theme
- (2014) Best Ending Theme
- (2014) Best Comedy
- (2014) Best Slice-of-Life
- (2014) Best Sports/Games/Tournament
- (2014) Best Horror/Supernatural/Mystery
- (2014) Best Action
- (2014) Best Adventure
- (2014) Best Drama
- (2014) Best Ecchi
- (2014) Best Romance (Romantic Comedy)
- (2014) Best Romance (Dramatic Romance)
- (2014) Favorite Anime Female
- (2014) Favorite Anime Male
- (2014) Favorite Anime Pairing/Couple
- (2015) Best Opening Theme
- (2015) Best Ending Theme
- (2015) Best Comedy
- (2015) Best Slice-of-Life
- (2015) Best Sports/Games/Tournament
- (2015) Best Horror/Supernatural/Mystery
- (2015) Best Action
- (2015) Best Adventure
- (2015) Best Drama
- (2015) Best Ecchi
- (2015) Best Romance
- (2015) Favorite Anime Female
- (2015) Favorite Anime Male
- (2015) Favorite Anime Couple
- (2015) Best Overall Series
- (2016) Best Action Series
- (2016) Best Adventure Series
- (2016) Best Comedy Series
- (2016) Best Drama Series
- (2016) Best Ecchi Series
- (2016) Best Fantasy/Supernatural Series
- (2016) Best Idols/Music Series
- (2016) Best Mystery Series
- (2016) Best Science-Fiction/Mecha Series
- (2016) Best Slice-of-Life Series
- (2016) Best Sports Series
- (2016) Best Game/Tournament Series
- (2016) Best OVA/OAV/ONA/SP
- (2016) Favorite Female Character
- (2016) Favorite Male Character
- (2016) Favorite Opening Theme
- (2016) Favorite Ending Theme
- (2016) Best Anime Series Overall
- Best of the Ecchi Category
- Best of the Sports Category
- Best of the Idol/Music Category
- Best of the Drama Category
- Best of the Comedy Category
- Best of the Action Category
- Best of the Mecha/Sci-Fi Category
- Best of the Game Category
- Best of the Mystery Category
- Best of the Fantasy/Supernatural Category
- Best of the Adventure Category
- Best Anime Overall
- Best Male Character of 2017
- Best Female Character of 2017
- Best Opening Theme of 2017
- Best Ending Theme of 2017
- 2018 OS Community Awards [Nomination Stage]
- 2018 OS Community Awards [Voting Stage]