A gameplay that doesn't get boring quick, graphics that is tolerable to the eye and story that makes sense and leaves you wanting to know more. These are what matters most in a game.
gameplay
graphics
music
story
gameplay and graphics
gameplay and music
gameplay and story
graphics and story
graphics and music
music and story
gameplay,graphics and music
gameplay,graphics and story
gameplay,music and story
replay value
multiplayer fun
A gameplay that doesn't get boring quick, graphics that is tolerable to the eye and story that makes sense and leaves you wanting to know more. These are what matters most in a game.
well me i love the gameplay, graphics and story :)
i don't mind about the music, for as long as the graphics and story is pretty good
:))
AC series is a highly recommended game, for those who has a liking with history perhaps..
Edit: Assassin's Creed
-I'm just your average Megpoid Gumi Fanboy-
Tetris does not have anime girls or happy endings. Or so i herd.
well I said gameplay, music, story, replay and multiplayer, all things i find important. I like graphics but what I find much more important isn't how good the graphics are but how good the art is.

we reached an age in which games must have good graphics, good music etc, yes the gameplay matters most but years ago there was an excuse for why graphics were sh*t, now we can get stunning looking games so all of them should look good, i hate to be like, yay i got some nice japanese game for my ps3, but then after turning it on seeing how sh*t it looks
Playing a game just because the graphics are good is like watching porn for the story.
This one was really hard one to answer, good game needs everything.
..you just rip all of your possible leftover hair if the gameplay does not work like you would want to, then again atleast I do not even touch two pixel games.
Then there is music and sound effects what make the stuff become alive? and you can drop the whole game if the story is basic recycle gum like *cough* harem animes.
So i answered replaying because the game has not clearly addicting enough if you do not want to play it again. Like lets say horrible f2p mmo where you farm through levels and need some serious boredom to levelup new alt.
OR at Skyrim to do new archer because after you hit 100skill on archery, its pure madness to gain any armor skills and you are too paper to play with spells? You clearly start deskheading at this point :D
Duh,.,Graphics.,Gameplay,.,and story must come all together,,..Graphics for visual attraction,.Gameplay of course so you will not be bored,.,and story so that you can engulf yourself at the game,.,
PS,.,Sorry for the wrong grammar
Though i can check all of them, you should have add games that are not that much demanding in system requirements even they are 3d games. like call of duty by infinity ward, but COD by tryarc is a bit heavy.
All I can say is all Final Fantasy series are good :D